I use the tall seat, like it the best over the three seats I've tried. The Shad and the Sargent where better than the oe but not by much, certainly not the 200 mile comfort I was looking for. With the oe, Shad and Sargent I always get a sore tailbone in maybe 100 miles. I don't get this till double that mileage on the tall seat. Just beware its tall, I'm 6ft, 32 inch leg and sometimes I'm on tippy toe depending on the surface.