Which of these is the best for the 650X

[Daimo]

Been doing some reading in this section, and obviously different people prefer different screens.  I need a screen to prevent the upcoming buffeting (not picked up the bike yet).  As I commute all year all weather, I want something to "hide" behind when its chucking it down with rain, and obviously to stop the buffeting I read a lot about. So far its down to:

Pyramid:
https://www.pyramid-plastics.co.uk/accessory.html?h=14_100322&accessoryCode=3599&d=DL650+VSTROM+Screen+2012+Touring+Style+Clear+&partNumber=400171W

Looks pretty good, a bit higher, but quite wide which "should" stop the majority of the rain.  £83

Or

Givi 3101DT

http://s1379.photobucket.com/user/Hrdwrguy/media/04691d6a137b430fa21d162e02adb1f5_zps1e5ff1c5.jpg.html

Very similar tye screen, wide, and slightly cheaper at £75

Then there's the other Givi screen, AF3101, all adjustable, but to be honest, its ruddy ugly so not on my preferred list.

So far its between the top two, I guess they are very similar.  Has anyone got any opinions on them both for what I need them for?  I'm on the motorway for about 17 miles per day, so if the rain is lashing down I want to be able to drop my head and shoulders down a bit to stop the majority of the rain hitting me.

[Joe Rocket]

I can't say about your 'top two' but the AF3101 covers the buffeting problem and even throws the rain forward! OK, beauty is in the eyes etc......... 

I like it!